Skip to Content

Breeding Your Goats for Optimal Milk Production

When it comes to establishing a successful dairy goat enterprise, selecting the right breed is a critical decision that significantly influences milk production and overall farm profitability. Different goat breeds have distinct characteristics, including milk yield, butterfat content, and adaptability to various environments.

If your goal is milk, then breeding for optimal milk production is really important!

In this article, we’ll explore key considerations and characteristics to help you make informed decisions when selecting a goat breed.  Once the breed is chosen, which individual goat you should choose for optimal milk production.

learn about what it takes to breed for milk production

*We get commissions for purchases made through links in this post. As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Click here for more info about cookies collected and our privacy policy.

Choosing Your Breed Based on Your Desired Outcome 

The first step is thinking through what you want in the long run. Each goat breed has different characteristics and strengths. 

  • Understanding Your Goals:

Before delving into specific breeds, it’s essential to define your goals for milk production. Are you aiming for a commercial dairy operation, supplying local markets, or simply providing for household needs? Clearly outlining your objectives will guide you in choosing a breed that aligns with your production goals.

After reading through this page, come back and look through the different Goat Breeds that you can choose from. 

  • Record Keeping:

Whether you’re just starting or have been raising goats for years, maintaining detailed records is indispensable in a successful breeding program. Keep comprehensive data on udder conformation, milk production, and health history. This information not only aids in making informed breeding decisions but also establishes a foundation for continuous improvement in future generations.

If you want to breed the best goats in your area who are also as productive as possible, you must start keeping good records. 

Get the best record-keeping system out there:



  • High Milk Yield:

Some goat breeds are renowned for their impressive milk production. Saanen, Alpine, and Nubian goats are recognized as high-yield dairy breeds. Saanens, in particular, are known for their exceptional milk production, making them a popular choice for commercial dairies.

But any of the other breeds can be excellent sources of milk for your family and community. With proper breeding and selection, even the smallest breeds can produce an astounding amount of milk!

  • Butterfat Content:

While high milk yield is important, the butterfat content of the milk also plays a crucial role, especially if you plan to produce cheese or other dairy products. Nigerian Dwarf goats, despite their smaller size, are known for their rich milk with high butterfat content, making them ideal for artisanal cheese production.

  • Adaptability to Climate:

Consider the climate and environmental conditions of your location. Some breeds are better suited to specific climates. For instance, Alpine goats are known for their adaptability to various climates, while Nubians may thrive better in warmer regions.

But any breed can adapt to a new environment. It may take several generations of breeding your goats in your area to produce the hardiest possible outcome, so don’t give up on what you have envisioned with your herd!

  • Size and Space Requirements:

Assess the size of your operation and the available space. Larger dairy breeds like Saanens and Alpines may require more space and substantial feeding, while smaller breeds like Nigerian Dwarfs are well-suited for smaller farms or backyard setups.

  • Temperament and Ease of Handling:

The temperament of the goat breed is another crucial factor, especially for those new to goat farming. Tamer and more docile breeds, such as LaManchas, are often easier to handle, making them suitable for beginners and smaller-scale operations.

But again, all breeds of goats will have those goats that are just what you need with a great personality and temperament, and on the flip side, those that you definitely want to cull and not reproduce. 

Just know that temperament is a critical factor in a successful breeding program. Goats with calm and docile temperaments are easier to handle, reducing stress during milking and management practices. A relaxed and cooperative temperament positively influences overall herd dynamics and human-animal interactions.

  • Reproductive Efficiency and Mothering Instincts:

Reproductive efficiency is key for maintaining a consistent milk supply. Research the breeding characteristics of different breeds, such as kidding intervals and ease of kidding. 

Most breeds of goats will have multiple kids per pregnancy. But Boar goats, if not bred for mothering capabilities can be known for their less-than-mothering instincts. 

A goat that struggles during pregnancy, birth, and after, and/or who isn’t a good mother are ones that you probably don’t want to keep around and continue breeding.  

  • Health and Disease Resistance:

Consider the health and disease resistance of the breed. Some breeds may be less susceptible to certain health issues, reducing the need for extensive veterinary care. This may come naturally to the breed or may have been through extensive breeding and culling.

Selecting the right goat breed for milk production is a nuanced decision that requires careful consideration of your goals, available resources, and environmental conditions. By evaluating factors such as milk yield, butterfat content, adaptability, temperament, and reproductive efficiency, you can make informed choices that set the foundation for a successful and sustainable dairy goat enterprise. Whether you are aiming for a commercial operation or a small-scale venture, the right breed can make a significant difference in the overall success of your milk production endeavors.

Breeding for strength, health, and hardiness is essential for building a robust and resilient herd. Evaluate the overall health history of potential breeding stock, considering factors such as resistance to common diseases and adaptability to varying environmental conditions. Strong, healthy goats contribute to the longevity and productivity of the herd.

After you’ve nailed down what you’d like in a goat herd, you’re ready to choose your first goats or decide which goat to add to your herd that will add the best genetics and results. 

Choosing Your Goats: Breeding for Optimal Milk Production

The points above are overall great points to consider as you choose your breed but once you’ve chosen that, there’s a lot more to consider. Let’s begin to explore what to look for in the actual goats you’re going to bring home. 

When I brought my first goats home…in milk…I didn’t know what to look for in conformation and udder attachments. At that time I hadn’t even thought of those terms. But what I did bring home were two darling does who were the perfect starter milking goats for me. 

If I’d been looking for perfect teats, udders, and conformation, I probably wouldn’t have gotten those two lovely girls. But I wouldn’t change it for the world. They were the best way for me to get started in the milking goat world. So don’t let all of the next information discourage and overwhelm you. It’s ok to get started with a couple of goats and go from there. Figure out what you want and what you like and don’t like. Get used to milking and then start to make decisions to improve your herd. 

In the intricate world of goat breeding, the careful selection of breeding stock is paramount for the success and sustainability of a herd. Udder characteristics, including attachment, fore udder conformation, ligaments, and teats, play a pivotal role in determining milk production and overall herd health.

Multifaceted Aspects of Better Breeding Selection

We’re going to explore the multifaceted aspects of better breeding selection, encompassing udder traits, structural conformation, and additional factors that contribute to the development of an exceptional and resilient goat herd.

The overall structure of the udder is a critical consideration in breeding selection. A well-structured udder should be deep, capacious, and symmetrical. Strong suspensory ligaments are essential for providing support, preventing pendulousness, and contributing to the longevity of the udder. Evaluate the medial and lateral ligaments for robustness and resilience.

A goat’s overall conformation goes beyond udder traits and encompasses body structure, balance, and correctness. Participating in a linear appraisal program provides valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of individual goats. Traits such as angularity, body capacity, and general appearance contribute to the overall quality of the breeding stock.

  • Strength

You want to choose a doe that is wide in the front end. The more depth they have in this area determines how strong they are. 

  • Dairyness

You want the doe you chose to have a look of “dairyness” about her. You’ll want her neck to be lean, her withers more pronounced, and to have a look of femininity and refinement. Her bones should have length, flatness, and cleanness.

  • Rump Angle 

The rump angle is an important aspect to look at in a doe. From the hip to the pin bones, you’re looking for it to be level. This angle will influence how well a doe kids and drains from her reproductive tract and it also influences how long her udder will be from fore to rear, how strong the attachments are, and the udder depth. 

  • Rump Width

Standing behind a doe, you’ll be able to see how wide her rump is. The wider the rump, the easier it will be for her to kid, and will be an indicator for how wide she is from front to back. But it will also be a good indicator for the potential of her udder width. Wider rump=wider udder.

  • Rear Legs

From the side view, the rear legs should have an angle with the feet placed more under the body.    

  • Fore udder Attachment

The foundation of productive dairy goats lies in the udder attachment and foreudder conformation. An ideal udder attachment is high and wide, facilitating optimal milk production and minimizing strain on the udder.

The fore udder should blend seamlessly with the body wall, avoiding abrupt transitions for optimal milk flow.

A “pocket” at the front of the udder where it attaches to the belly of the goat has fewer lateral ligaments. You want the fore udder to be snug and strong and to extend and attach further under the goat with no pocket at all.  

  • Rear Udder Height

When you’re looking at the rear of your goat, you want the udder attachment, the top of the udder, to be as high as possible. This will indicate how much capacity the udder will be able to hold, how well it will hold up after repeat kiddings, and if it will keep its shape and position through the years.

  • Rear Udder Arch 

Imagine a goat with an udder that comes to a point at the top compared to one that is very round, wide, and curving. You want the udder to be the latter. Like the udder height, the udder arch will determine how much milk capacity there is and how well it will hold its shape. 

  • Medial Suspensory Ligament

  This ligament is a very important one. It is the support of the udder and is found between each of the sides of the udder and is responsible for keeping the teats in place and the udder elevated. 

The bottom of the udder will be flat, with a bulging udder floor when this ligament isn’t strong. But will have an extreme cleft when it’s at its strongest. 

  • Udder Depth

You want a nice, large udder with the floor of the udder extremely high. If the floor of the udder is below the hocks, there is more potential for injury or mastitis infections. 

  • Teat Placement

The best teat placements will be closer to the center of the udder. This will prevent injuries and will make them easier to milk. 

  • Teat Diameter

The wider the teats, the easier to milk and the more capacity for milk. 

  • Functional Teats and Orifice Size

Functional teats are indispensable for efficient milking and kid access. Optimal teat length, placement, and spacing are essential considerations. Teats should be pliable, allowing for ease of milking by hand or machine. Additionally, consider the orifice size, as larger orifices can enhance milk flow.

  • Rear udder, when viewed from the side

When looking at the udder from the side, you want an udder that bulges and extends behind the rear leg when the legs are squarely placed beneath her. The more it extends behind that leg, the more milk she will produce. 

  • Color Considerations

While color may be a secondary consideration, it can play a role in breed standards and market preferences. Some breed associations have specific color requirements, and breeders may choose to prioritize or avoid certain color traits based on these standards and personal preferences.

  • Line Breeding Strategies

Line breeding is a deliberate breeding practice aimed at reinforcing desirable traits within a herd. When employing linebreeding, it is crucial to strike a balance between preserving favorable traits and avoiding excessive inbreeding. Careful record-keeping and pedigree analysis are essential tools for successful line breeding programs.

It’s safe to breed a daughter to father, grandfather to granddaughter, and uncle to niece. Stay away from breeding full brother to sister. 

And only begin to do this after you understand the strengths and weaknesses of your herd. If you know you have very strong bucks without any weaknesses, this can be something to begin to experiment with in your own herd. 

Using Linear Appraisal Information

You can use all of the information on this page as you begin to select your first goats or as you begin to move forward in making decisions for which goat to add to your herd. 

If you own a doe that isn’t strong in one area, you can choose a buck whose lineage is strong in that area and the kids from that match will have an improvement in that area. 

As you can see, breeding for optimal milk production can be done and you can do it!

The meticulous process of better breeding selection involves a holistic approach, considering not only udder traits but also overall conformation, temperament, health, and more. A judicious blend of these factors contributes to the development of a resilient, high-performing goat herd. Through careful consideration of udder attachments, structural conformation, and additional attributes, breeders can advance their breeding programs and cultivate a herd that excels in both productivity and adaptability.

Take some time to read this excellent information: 

Getting the Best Breeding Results for Your Goat Herd

When you bring home your new goat, your biosecurity needs to be top notch!

I accept the Privacy Policy